Suppose you are outside your home or in a public place when the police arrive and begin asking questions. Law enforcement officers have a duty to protect the community they serve, its citizens and their property. The law gives police certain powers to help them perform that duty.
Police have the power to approach persons and ask them questions. Simply because you are approached and questioned by the police does not mean you are suspected of having committed a crime. All citizens are encouraged to cooperate with the police so those who break the law can be brought to justice, but, with one exception, discussed below, you have no legal duty to answer any question, and you may refuse to answer. This is called the right of silence. You should never lie to a law enforcement officer, however. If you do, you can get into trouble for “obstructing official business.”
Suppose you are walking down a street when a police officer confronts you and says: “Stop. I need to ask you some questions.” A person is “stopped,” or “detained,” when an officer uses enough force, or a show of authority, to make a reasonable person feel he or she is not free to leave. If, in addition to calling out for you to stop and using his or her authority to make you stop, the officer also pulls out a weapon or uses a threatening tone of voice, it would be even clearer that you have been "stopped." If the officer interferes with your liberty to move about, he or she should first have a reasonable suspicion that you have been involved in a crime. The officer would need to support this suspicion later (should the matter should wind up in court) by referring to specific facts that prompted the suspicion.
The police do not have to tell you that you are a suspect or that they intend to arrest you, but if they use force or a show of authority to keep you from leaving, they probably consider you a suspect, even if you were the person who called the police. If they read or recite your Miranda rights, they suspect you have committed a crime.
You have the right, if you are stopped, to refuse to answer any questions for any reason or no reason. You can invoke your right to silence by saying, "I refuse to answer any questions" or "I want to speak to a lawyer" or "I wish to remain silent." If you do not clearly invoke your right to silence with such a statement, you may subject yourself to continued questioning by police.
There is one exception to your right to silence: According to Ohio law since April 2006, if you are in a public place and under certain circumstances, you must give your name, address and date of birth to an officer. If you fail to provide this information under such circumstances, you will be committing a fourth-degree misdemeanor and may be arrested.
Also, if you are only being stopped, you can refuse to give your consent for an officer to search your person, vehicle or home. Your refusal will force the police officer to legally justify any search made without your consent. Be aware, however, that Ohio law does permit some limited searches (such as patdowns) in "stop" situations in order to search for weapons.
Further, anything you say can be used as evidence against you. Sometimes people think that what they are saying won't incriminate them, but it can provide a link in a chain of information that could incriminate them.
Even if you believe the officer has no grounds to stop and question you, do not argue with or resist the police. Arguing or resisting will not help you, and may make it more likely that the police will arrest you and bring criminal charges against you. It may also give them grounds to bring even more criminal charges against you, which can make it harder for you to get out of jail on bail if you are charged. Once officers no longer have grounds to detain you, they should say you are free to go before asking to search you or your car.
An arrest is different from a stop. A stop involves brief questioning in the place where you were detained. If the officer wants to hold you longer, or decides to take you elsewhere, such as to the police station, he or she is no longer just stopping you, but is arresting you. An arrest deprives you of your freedom of movement for an even longer period of time than a stop, so the law limits the instances when arrests can be made.
You may be arrested by a police officer who personally saw you violate any state statute, city ordinance or federal law. Police arrest powers vary depending on the seriousness of the offense. The important thing is that the officer sees the violation.
An arrest warrant is a legal document, issued by a judge or a clerk of the courts, directing the police or the sheriff to arrest you and take you into custody. This document does not have to be on any particular form. The arresting officer is not required to have the warrant in hand when you are arrested. The officer must show you the warrant within a reasonable time after you are arrested and give you a copy. If the officer fails to do so, tell your attorney later.
Even if you believe the officer has no grounds to arrest you, do not argue with or resist the police. You have no right to argue about why you are being arrested or about your guilt or innocence at the time of the arrest. Arguing or resisting will not help you. It will mean the police can bring additional criminal charges against you, and may make it harder for you to get out of jail on bail if you are charged.
The police will search you for weapons, handcuff you, transport you to jail, and photograph and fingerprint you for identification.
If you are not under arrest or if police do not have a search warrant (a court order allowing them to search), the police may ask you to let them search your car, your home and/or other possessions. You can refuse to consent to these searches.
You have a right to be free from unreasonable searches and seizures. Most of the searches for which an officer might ask your consent would require the officer to first get a warrant from a judge, unless you consent and give up this right.
Only a judge can decide whether the search is proper before that search is conducted. There is no penalty for exercising your right to have the judge decide whether to allow the search. Your refusal to consent to a search cannot be used against you.
If you are unsure how to respond to an officer's request, assert your right to counsel and discuss the request with your attorney before doing or saying anything.
Since July 1, 2011, Ohio law has required that a law enforcement agency must collect and forward a DNA specimen to the Bureau of Criminal Identification and Investigation when the agency arrests a person 18 years or older for a felony.
Do not argue with the police. You cannot talk your way out of being investigated, arrested or prosecuted. Any explanation you give the police may give them more information than they already have, so it’s often wise to save your explanation and defenses for court.
If you have been arrested, the police believe you committed a crime. Their job is to investigate and gather evidence. Telling the police your side without a lawyer present is usually a bad idea, even if you believe you have done nothing wrong.
Always pay close attention to what happens when you first encounter the police and afterward. Try to memorize who was there to see and hear what happened. Sometimes the court needs to look into what happened to you while you were in custody. It will help you if you can later fully inform your counsel about these events.
Do not tell your family and friends all about it or ask non-lawyers for legal advice. It is possible that they may be ordered to appear at trial to repeat what you said.
Do not talk to another inmate or a corrections officer about your case. A conviction may result from a "jailhouse confession."
Rely on your lawyer to advise and defend you no matter what you did or did not do. Legal ethics rules keep your attorney from disclosing without your permission any information you give him or her during the attorney-client relationship. However, your attorney may disclose your intention to commit a crime and the information necessary to prevent the crime. Also, your attorney has an ethical duty to keep you from offering testimony that he or she knows is not true.
Within 72 hours after your arrest, the judge must:
You are entitled to have a record made by a court reporter or tape recorder of what has happened in the courtroom. Then, if a question later arises, you have evidence of what happened when you were in court.
© February 2015 Ohio State Bar Association. Used with permission.
Document last updated 2/23/2015. Please note: The Ohio State Bar Association periodically updates its LawFacts Pamphlets. For updated or additional information, please visit the LawFacts Pamphlets webpage.
© 2019 Palecek, McIlvaine, Hoffmann & Morse Co., LPA